Truss vs. Sunak: Who will become the PM and what they will do for solving the climate crisis?

By Asitha Jayawardena

This story first appeared in Climate and Capital Media on 2 September 2022. The link appears at the end of this article.

The race between Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak for the next Conservative Leader as well as the next PM of the UK.

Despite deadly heat, drought and runaway energy costs, climate change doesn’t top the agenda of the two U.K. leadership contenders.

In late August, six U.K. water providers, including Thames Water with 15 million customers, imposed household hosepipe bans prohibiting water use for gardens and lawns, washing windows and cars and other common uses following extreme drought conditions. Those who fail to head the hosepipe water ban face fines of up to £1000. The country renowned for its rain now finds itself without water.

The bans come on the heels of what the U.K.’s Environmental Agency says is its driest conditions in nearly 90 years. Southwest England is in drought, and 11 of the 14 Environment Agency areas are now impacted, including Devon and Cornwall. On top of these challenges, the U.K. has suffered temperatures of up to 40.3C this summer in three heat waves that are estimated to have caused more than 1,000 deaths.

Drought conditions have led to low river flows not only in the U.K. but across Europe, along with forest fires and heat that has devastated crops. Almost half of the 27-country European Union is under drought warnings.

Meanwhile, the U.K.’s High Court ruled in July that the government’s Net Zero Strategy is in breach of its Climate Change Act in a legal challenge brought by ClientEarth, Friends of the Earth, the Good Law Project and environmental campaigner Jo Wheatley saying the strategy fails to provide sufficient details on how it would meet its targets.

As the U.K. stares down growing climate change impacts, it’s in the midst of a national leadership crisis. With the departure of Boris Johnson, 180,000 to 200,000 Conservative Party members will vote to select the next Conservative Leader as well as the next Prime Minister in September. A number of early contenders have already been eliminated, leaving two options: Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak.

While both candidates have committed to a net-zero target, in true Conservative Party fashion, environmental policies are dropping down the priority agenda in favour of economic rhetoric as the leadership challenge escalates.

Liz Truss

Truss, the favourite to win according to U.K. media, has been Secretary of State for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs since 2021 and was a former environment secretary.

If selected for No 10 Downing Street, she has said she will strip out green levies on energy bills as energy costs skyrocket due to rising gas prices that are impacting global energy security. The U.K.’s green levies help fund a range of environmental policies including support for the transition to the clean energy alternatives that would help the country wean itself off of expensive gas and a market beholden to Russia. According to Carbon Brief, the proposed Truss plan to scrap levies is likely to result in only a 3% reduction in ever more expensive consumer energy bills.

Truss is hostile to solar power and wants farmers to produce food instead of what she says is “filling fields with paraphernalia like solar farms.” During her time as Environment Secretary, she introduced cuts to solar farm subsidies, viewing photovoltaic panels as a scar on the U.K.’s natural landscape and a hindrance to food production. And she backs fracking.

Although Truss has confirmed her commitment to achieving net zero, she suggests that net zero issue is a problem for businesses rather than the government to solve. There are also indications that she could put climate change on the back burner when it comes to the government’s international development strategy and spending.

Rishi Sunak

Rishi Sunak was the former Chancellor of the Exchequer until he resigned on 5 July 2022. If selected for the big job at 10 Downing Street, Sunak says he would re-establish the Department of Energy, which was absorbed into the Department of Business in 2016. He would also create a new Energy Security Committee. He has announced that he wants the U.K.’s Value Added Tax or VAT to be cut from energy bills for at least one year to combat growing energy prices.

Sunak is also hostile to solar power and has also said he thinks farms in the U.K. should produce food rather than clean energy. Under his watch, Sunak has said that rewilding land, or allowing it to return to its natural state, “should not take place at the expense of food production.”

On onshore wind power, Sunak’s statements have him blowing both ways but most recently he seems to be against expansion. His opponent Truss has accused him of indecisiveness on that issue and with onshore and offshore wind farms generating as much as 24% of the U.K.’s electricity in 2020, a clear national strategy would be prudent.

Sunak, who says his daughters are the climate change “experts in his household,” has confirmed his commitment to achieving net zero target. At COP26, he outlined a vision of making the U.K. the “world’s first net-zero financial centre” and to contribute to global efforts to “rewire the financial system for net-zero.” Clearly rewiring for net zero is his go-to line but what that actually means remains largely unclear as pointed out by U.K. environmental leaders.

Innovation is another Sunak catch phrase and, oddly, recycling. He recently told the U.K. media, “this is something we are obsessive about in my house. I know it’s a pain and you need a lot of bins, but it is very good for the environment.” Much like the Conservative Party’s policies in general.

Winter is coming

In a recent hour-long debate, just two minutes were dedicated to climate change despite the issue now impacting millions of Britons. Neither candidate has given any indication that they would step up to lead on climate change leaving the country not only facing the economic challenges of Brexit, but a leadership vacuum as the world ramps up efforts to reduce emissions to stave off deadly global warming.

Just over one week before the PM Boris Johnson resigned on 7 July 2022, the U.K. Climate Change Committee (CCC) submitted an assessment of how best to reduce the greenhouse gases emissions causing climate change in its “2022 Progress Report to Parliament.” Neither candidate has indicated if they will implement the report’s recommendations despite being given a clear roadmap for action.

Given the Conservative Party’s lacklustre track records on green issues, including climate change, the two rivals for the PM role have “a lot of reassuring to do,” according to Greenpeace U.K.’s head of politics, Rebecca Newsom.

Meanwhile, with climate change impacts increasing and energy prices soaring, in the U.K., winter is coming.

More…

The original post appeared on Climate and Capital Media on 2 September 2022:

As Boris exits stage left, two climate skeptics fight for the top U.K. job

6 comments

  1. Hello from the UK

    Many thanks for your post. I consider the climate change debate a red herring to distract form the increasing issues of the poisoning of the planet via the many chemicals produced by big pharma etc.

    The issues with plastic and numerous neuro-toxins is very serious and tend to be ignored in the pursuit for reducing carbon dioxide, ignoring the fact that it is required to enable plants to grow.

    If we in the UK had properly looked at nuclear power we might have realised the radiation issues are not quite what they have been made out to be and we might not be in the position we are now.

    Kind regards

    Like

  2. This was informative, Thank you! I just read is morning that Liz Truss won and as an American, didn’t know anything about her. I’m deeply disappointed that American media is only obsessed with one really annoying man as if nothing else is going on in this country and the rest of the world! It was only after being in Canada this last weekend that I learned about the NASA mission back to the moon, which should have been a more important news story, in my opinion.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.